
Short answer: Compare both over five years, not one season: count product, labour, machines, training, compliance and record keeping for herbicides; machines, labour, fuel and parts for mowing. Add the cost of rules that limit herbicide use and the results each method achieves.
Why five years
Herbicide can look cheap in one year, while a machine is a large first-year cost. Over five years, machine cost spreads out, and herbicide rules or resistance can change the picture.
Cost items
| Herbicide programme | Mowing programme |
|---|---|
| Product | Machine purchase or hire |
| Labour and PPE | Labour |
| Training and licences | Fuel or power |
| Records and compliance | Parts and service |
| Buffer zones and restrictions | Transport |
Simple model
- List each cost per year for five years.
- Add them up for each programme.
- Divide by area to get cost per hectare per year.
- Note results: weed cover, complaints, compliance.
Remote mowing
A tracked remote mower can take over banks and slopes where both spraying and manual mowing are slow or risky. Use the mowing time calculator for labour hours.
Mixed programmes
Many sites use both: mowing for most areas and targeted spot treatment for invasive weeds.
Non-cost factors
Public opinion, water protection rules, staff safety and changes in what products are allowed all affect the choice. Some councils and estates have moved away from herbicide for these reasons even where mowing costs more. Record them next to the figures so decision-makers see the full picture.
Filling the five-year sheet
| Line | Herbicide programme | Mowing programme |
|---|---|---|
| Year 1 setup | Training, licences, PPE, spray kit | Machine purchase or hire, trailer, training |
| Yearly running | Product, labour, records | Labour, fuel or power, parts |
| Compliance | Buffer zones, notices, audits | Site safety, traffic plans where needed |
| Results | Weed cover, regrowth, complaints | Weed cover, regrowth, complaints |
| Five-year total | Sum | Sum |
Use your own figures. No prices are given here because they vary too much by country and site.

Worked example: labour hours on banks
Banks are where the two programmes differ most. Say a council has 10 km of steep bank, cut or sprayed three times a year. For the mowing programme, count passes: bank height divided by the cutting width, plus one, times the bank length. A 6 m bank with a 1,200 mm deck needs about six passes, so 10 km of bank is about 60 km of travel per round. Use the time calculator with your measured speed to get hours.
For the spraying programme, count the hours for mixing, spraying, notices and records for the same banks. Put both into the five-year sheet.
When a mixed programme wins
- Most of the area is mown on a regular cycle.
- Invasive weeds get spot treatment under the local plan.
- Banks and slopes go to the remote mower to save labour.
- Buffers near water stay mown, not sprayed.
Data to collect before you compare
- Area treated each year by site type: banks, verges, beds and hard surfaces.
- Hours per visit and visits per year for each method, from job sheets.
- Product used per year, from stock records.
- Training, licence and record-keeping time for spraying.
- Machine hours, fuel or power and parts for mowing.
- Complaints and regrowth notes, so results are compared as well as cost.
Use the last full year of records where you have them. Estimates can fill the gaps, but mark them so the comparison is easy to check later.
Common mistakes
- Comparing one year only.
- Leaving compliance and record time out of the herbicide side.
- Leaving parts and transport out of the mowing side.
- Not recording results, so cost is compared without outcome.
Presenting the comparison
Decision-makers need one page. Show the five-year totals side by side, the cost per hectare per year, and a short list of non-cost factors: staff safety, water protection, public feedback and rule changes. Add a note on what was assumed, such as the number of cuts or sprays per year. If the assumptions change, the sheet can be updated in minutes.
Related MERI pages
- Chemical-free weed control
- Mowing time calculator
- Integrated vegetation management
- Mulching vs burning vs herbicide
Frequently asked questions
Why compare over five years?
Machine costs spread out and herbicide rules can change.
What costs come with herbicides?
Product, labour, PPE, training, records and compliance.
What costs come with mowing?
Machine, labour, fuel, parts and transport.
Can both be used?
Yes, mowing plus targeted spot treatment.
Send us your site details
Tell us the job, area, slope and country. MERI replies within 24 hours.
Need a mower recommendation for your terrain or project?
Get a Quote